✕ No deal Status unconfirmed Season 15, Ep. 12 🐾 Pet Products

Jay's Pet Butter on Shark Tank

Jay's Pet Butter makes peanut butter formulated specifically for dogs, without ingredients that are unsafe for pets. It is designed to be used as a treat, for hiding pills, or for filling enrichment and lick toys.

Check price on Amazon

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never affects what we write. How we make money

🖨️ Giving this as a gift? Print the "story behind your gift" card

⏱ Jay's Pet Butter in 30 seconds

The ask$50K for 10%Valued at $500K
In the tankNo dealWalked out without a Shark
After the showWent it alone
TodayStatus unconfirmed

Jay's Pet Butter Shark Tank deal

Asked for: $50,000 for 10%
Asking valuation: $500K
Result: No deal
Founders: Jay Cutler and Brandan Fokken
From: -
Aired: Jan 26, 2024

Would you have invested in Jay's Pet Butter?

The pitch

Jay Cutler and Brandan Fokken pitched Jay's Pet Butter in Shark Tank Season 15, Episode 12 (aired Jan 26, 2024). They asked for $50,000 in exchange for 10% equity, valuing the business at $500K. They left the Tank without a deal.

What happened to Jay's Pet Butter after Shark Tank?

Status unconfirmed Last checked November 1, 2026

Our checks

Nov 1, 2026: Removed the link to the company's website because the website's home page is gone.

We couldn't confirm whether Jay's Pet Butter is still operating. Its website did not respond at our last check (November 2026). Readers can share updates in the reviews.

📝 Know something we don't? Suggest an update

Reviews of Jay's Pet Butter

No reviews yet. Have you tried Jay's Pet Butter? Tell other shoppers what you think.

Frequently asked questions

Did Jay's Pet Butter get a deal on Shark Tank?

No. Jay's Pet Butter did not get a deal on Shark Tank after asking for $50,000 for 10%.

Is Jay's Pet Butter still in business?

We couldn't confirm whether Jay's Pet Butter is still operating. Its website did not respond at our last check (November 2026). Readers can share updates in the reviews.

What season and episode was Jay's Pet Butter on Shark Tank?

Jay's Pet Butter appeared in Season 15, Episode 12, which first aired on January 26, 2024.

Where can I buy Jay's Pet Butter?

Search for Jay's Pet Butter on Amazon or major retailers; availability varies.

What was Jay's Pet Butter's valuation on Shark Tank?

The founders valued Jay's Pet Butter at $500,000 when they entered the Tank.